Back

ⓘ Blog | Comparative law - academic disciplines. Comparative law is the study of differences and similarities between the law of different countries. More specificall ..



Comparative law
                                     

Comparative law

Comparative law is the study of differences and similarities between the law of different countries. More specifically, it involves the study of the different legal "systems" in existence in the world, including the common law, the civil law, socialist law, Canon law, Jewish Law, Islamic law, Hindu law, and Chinese law. It includes the description and analysis of foreign legal systems, even where no explicit comparison is undertaken. The importance of comparative law has increased enormously in the present age of internationalism, economic globalization, and democratization.

                                     

1. History

The origins of modern Comparative Law can be traced back to Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz in 1667 in his Latin-language book Nova Methodus Discendae Docendaeque Iurisprudentiae New Methods of Studying and Teaching Jurisprudence. Chapter 7 Presentation of Law as the Project for all Nations, Lands and Times introduces the idea of classifying Legal Systems into several families. Notably, a few years later, Leibniz introduced an idea of Language families.

Although every Legal System is unique, Comparative Law through studies of their similarities and differences allows for classification of Legal Systems, wherein Law Families is the basic level of the classification. The main differences between Law Families are found in the sources of Law, the role of court precedents, the origin and development of the Legal System. Montesquieu is generally regarded as an early founding figure of comparative law. His comparative approach is obvious in the following excerpt from Chapter III of Book I of his masterpiece, De lesprit des lois 1748; first translated by Thomas Nugent, 1750:

he political and civil laws of each nation. should be adapted in such a manner to the people for whom they are framed that it should be a great chance if those of one nation suit another.

They should be in relation to the nature and principle of each government: whether they form it, as may be said of politic laws; or whether they support it, as in the case of civil institutions.

They should be in relation to the climate of each country, to the quality of its soil, to its situation and extent, to the principal occupation of the natives, whether husbandmen, huntsmen, or shepherds: they should have relation to the degree of liberty which the constitution will bear; to the religion of the inhabitants, to their inclinations, riches, numbers, commerce, manners, and customs.

Also, in Chapter XI entitled How to compare two different Systems of Laws of Book XXIX, discussing the French and English systems for punishment of false witnesses, he advises that "to determine which of those systems is most agreeable to reason, we must take them each as a whole and compare them in their entirety." Yet another place where Montesquieus comparative approach is evident is the following, from Chapter XIII of Book XXIX:

As the civil laws depend on the political institutions, because they are made for the same society, whenever there is a design of adopting the civil law of another nation, it would be proper to examine beforehand whether they have both the same institutions and the same political law.

The modern founding figure of comparative and anthropological jurisprudence was Sir Henry Maine, a British jurist and legal historian. In his 1861 work Ancient Law: Its Connection with the Early History of Society, and Its Relation to Modern Ideas, he set out his views on the development of legal institutions in primitive societies and engaged in a comparative discussion of Eastern and Western legal traditions. This work placed comparative law in its historical context and was widely read and influential.

The first university course on the subject was established at the University of Oxford in 1869, with Maine taking up the position of professor.

Comparative law in the US was brought by a legal scholar fleeing persecution in Germany, Rudolf Schlesinger. Schlesinger eventually became professor of comparative law at Cornell Law School helping to spread the discipline throughout the US.

                                     

2. Purpose

Comparative law is an academic discipline that involves the study of legal systems, including their constitutive elements and how they differ, and how their elements combine into a system.

Several disciplines have developed as separate branches of comparative law, including comparative constitutional law, comparative administrative law, comparative civil law, comparative commercial law in the sense of business organisations and trade, and comparative criminal law. Studies of these specific areas may be viewed as micro- or macro-comparative legal analysis, i.e. detailed comparisons of two countries, or broad-ranging studies of several countries. Comparative civil law studies, for instance, show how the law of private relations is organised, interpreted and used in different systems or countries. The purposes of comparative law are:

  • To attain a deeper knowledge of the legal systems in effect
  • To perfect the legal systems in effect
  • Possibly, to contribute to a unification of legal systems, of a smaller or larger scale cf. for instance, the UNIDROIT initiative
                                     

3. Relationship with other legal subjects

Comparative law is different from general jurisprudence i.e. legal theory and from public and private international law. However, it helps inform all of these areas of normativity.

For example, comparative law can help international legal institutions, such as those of the United Nations System, in analyzing the laws of different countries regarding their treaty obligations. Comparative law would be applicable to private international law when developing an approach to interpretation in a conflicts analysis. Comparative law may contribute to legal theory by creating categories and concepts of general application. Comparative law may also provide insights into the question of legal transplants, i.e. the transplanting of law and legal institutions from one system to another. The notion of legal transplants was coined by Alan Watson, one of the worlds renowned legal scholars specializing in comparative law.

Also, the usefulness of comparative law for sociology of law and law and economics and vice versa is very large. The comparative study of the various legal systems may show how different legal regulations for the same problem function in practice. Conversely, sociology of law and law & economics may help comparative law answer questions, such as:

  • How do regulations in different legal systems really function in the respective societies?
  • Are legal rules comparable?
  • How do the similarities and differences between legal systems get explained?


                                     

4.1. Classifications of legal systems Arminjon, Nolde, and Wolff

Arminjon, Nolde, and Wolff believed that, for purposes of classifying the then contemporary legal systems of the world, it was required that those systems per se get studied, irrespective of external factors, such as geographical ones. They proposed the classification of legal system into seven groups, or so-called families, in particular the

  • Russian group
  • German group
  • Hindu group
  • Scandinavian group, comprising the laws of Denmark, Norway, Sweden, Finland, and Iceland
  • Islamic group used in the Muslim world
  • French group, under which they also included the countries that codified their law either in 19th or in the first half of the 20th century, using the Napoleonic code civil of year 1804 as a model; this includes countries and jurisdictions such as Italy, Portugal, Spain, Romania, Louisiana, various South American states such as Brazil, Quebec, Saint Lucia, the Ionian Islands, Egypt, and Lebanon
  • English group, including, inter alia, England, the United States, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand
                                     

4.2. Classifications of legal systems David

Rene David proposed the classification of legal systems, according to the different ideology inspiring each one, into five groups or families:

  • Civil law subgroup whose jurisprudence is based on post-classical Roman Law
  • Common law subgroup originating in English law
  • Western laws, a group subdivided into the
  • Soviet Law
  • Chinese Law
  • Jewish Law
  • Hindu Law
  • Muslim Law

Especially with respect to the aggregating by David of the Civil and Common laws into a single family, David argued that the antithesis between the Common law and Civil law systems, is of a technical rather than of an ideological nature. Of a different kind is, for instance, the antithesis between, say, Italian and American laws, and of a different kind than between the Soviet, Muslim, Hindu, or Chinese laws. According to David, the Civil law legal systems included those countries where legal science was formulated according to Roman law, whereas Common law countries are those dominated by judge-made law. The characteristics that he believed uniquely differentiate the Western legal family from the other four are:

  • liberal democracy
  • capitalist economy
  • Christian religion
                                     

4.3. Classifications of legal systems Zweigert and Kotz

Konrad Zweigert and Hein Kotz propose a different, multidimensional methodology for categorizing laws, i.e. for ordering families of laws. They maintain that, to determine such families, five criteria should be taken into account, in particular: the historical background, the characteristic way of thought, the different institutions, the recognized sources of law, and the dominant ideology. Using the aforementioned criteria, they classify the legal systems of the world into six families:

  • Family of the laws of the Far East China and Japan
  • Nordic family
  • German family
  • Common law family
  • Roman family
  • Religious family

Up to the second German edition of their introduction to comparative law, Zweigert and Kotz also used to mention Soviet or socialist law as another family of laws.

                                     

5. Professional associations

  • International Law Association
  • American Association of Law Libraries
  • International Association of Procedural Law
  • American Society of Comparative Law
  • International Association of Judicial Independence and World Peace

Users also searched:

...
                                     
Comparative law Comparative law Britannica. What meant comparative law? In strict sense, it is the theoretical study of legal systems by comparison with each other, and has a tradition going back. .. Comparative law International & Comparative GW Law The George. Overview. Reflecting the increased importance a basic understanding of international comparative law principles to legal education and practice, every. .. Comparative law Asian Journal of Comparative Law Cambridge Core. , examination legal systems and relationships of to social sciences. The expression comparative law is a. .. Comparative law American Society of Comparative Law: ASCL. Learn about the Indiana International Comparative Law Review at IU McKinney and find out how you can get involved.. .. Comparative law LLM in Comparative School Law University of San Diego. The & Quarterly ICLQ publishes papers on public private international, comparative law, human rights and European. .. Comparative law The Chinese Journal of Comparative Law Oxford Academic. Publishes on all disciplines of, including cross disciplinary legal studies. Papers address significant issues in comparative law and to.. .. Center for Comparative Legal Studies and Post Conflict Peacebuilding. The program engages research, advocacy public education in a multitude areas of international and comparative law, including human rights.. .. Comparative law International & Comparative Law Quarterly Cambridge Core. Key Program Features. For almost 40 years, LLM in Comparative has provided international law school graduates with the opportunity to design a. .. Comparative law International and Comparative Harvard Law School. Overview Program. Law Specialization is at the heart UCLA School of Laws robust International and Comparative. .. Comparative Law: Study of Similarities or Differences? Oxford. Comparative. This course is designed prepare deal effectively with law, lawyers and foreign clients. It gives you skills to move. Comparative law The American Journal of Comparative Law Oxford Academic. official journal Society and the pre eminent American publication of scholarship on comparative law. Publishes articles. .. Comparative law Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law: SAGE Journals. More than 93 percent of the worlds citizens live systems that are not Our students take international and comparative law courses, intern in legal. .. Comparative law Global Journal of Comparative Law brill. Clients demand that their skilled in and comparative law. Transactional lawyers need be able to negotiate complex international. .. UPDATE: Comparative Law GlobaLex. For writers, this forms part the definition of law. Some comparative lawyers have generally emphasized differences, while others see. .. Comparative law Indiana International & Comparative Law Review: IU Robert H. Global Journal is peer reviewed periodical that provides a dynamic platform for the dissemination of ideas on comparative law and. .. Comparative law 430: Comparative Chicago Kent College of Law. The Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law warmly invites proposals special issues. For information, click below. More. show Slide 1. .. International and Comparative Law Specialization Overview. Role in the Social Sciences September 12, 2020 Photo by Sawyer Bengtson on UnsplashThe American Society of Comparative Law. .. Comparative law About the International and Comparative Law Program, Jessica. Asian Journal Comparative AsJCL leading forum for research discussion the law and legal systems of Asia. It embraces work that is. .. Comparative law International Academy of Comparative Law. Academie internationale de droit compare International Academy of Comparative Law..

Law as an Academic Discipline by Hanoch Dagan SSRN.

These specialized areas include international law, environmental law, intellectual Thus, an academic year course with two hours of credit each semester is Government Contracts International Law & Other Disciplines Clinics Skills. The Cold War and Comparative Law UC Hastings Scholarship. DISCIPLINES IN THE EDUCATION OF ATTORNEYS. 842. sponsoring more international academic programs, opening research centers with global. Course Descriptions School of Law University of San Diego. Jun 3, 2016 Thanks to these scholars, the field of comparative constitutional law has law has fallen between the chairs of academic disciplines and, as a. ERIC EJ1118307 International Festival of Student Films as the. Jun 1, 2005 Rethinking the Purpose and Function of International Law, 27 Loy. L.A. Intl. as an academic discipline and a style of thought. Id. at 2 3.


Journals of the Century in Law William & Mary Law School.

The ROCs professionalization of the discipline of international law, which was based. returning to enhance Chinas academia in international law. Prominent. Publications & Journals Yale Law School. I thank all of them for their input. 1. Sreejith: Whither International Law, Thither Space Law: A Discipline in Tra. Published by CWSL Scholarly Commons, 2007. Whither International Law, Thither Space Law CWSL Scholarly. The program in Comparative Literature and the History of Ideas provides an for example, law, education, journalism, administration, comparative literature,.


Law As An Academic Discipline And Its Different Branches Bartleby.

Tive law as a whole centres versus peripheries of scholarly projects and interests. It is of course a risk for a comparative lawyer to use disciplines foreign to. MILITARY LAW PRACTITIONERS AND ACADEMIC DISCOURSE: A. Study a Bachelors degree in International Law to discover how justice is maintained at a global level. Law and Other Disciplines Georgetown Law. In the same manner that comparative law cannot be pursued without regard to legal Two seemingly incongruous academic disciplines rational choice theory. Relationship with other. We still speak of legal theory in educational contexts, while we mention. which the discipline of comparative legal cultures and its focus on the whole variety of. Discipline of Comparative Law Oxford Scholarship. Are diverse: in comparison with other academic disciplines, as these have developed over well as his The Mind and Method of the Legal Academic 2012, pp. Asian Law Center UW School of Law. Sep 24, 2019 The Program in Law and Public Affairs LAPA at Princeton invites outstanding faculty members of any discipline, independent scholars, lawyers, and by leading academic and practical experts on American, international,.





Rapoport Center for Human Rights and Justice Ralph Texas Law.

International law – Boundaries between law and other disciplines, including comparative law I examine the fields boundaries as a scholarly discipline.1 The. Comparative Law and its Clients. Mar 20, 2015 In both the anthropology of law and comparative legal studies, the. law unique vis à vis other academic disciplines, form the anthropology or. Outline of academic disciplines Basic Knowledge 101. An academic discipline or field of study is a branch of knowledge have branches, and these are often called sub disciplines. There is no. Comparative law. Scientific Reason and the Discipline of International Law EJIL. Across a range of academic disciplines has called into question long held assumptions about the separation of religion and law in the modern world. It has. ESADE Law School ESADE. Environmental and Energy Law General ​ International Legal Studies Global Health First, some other area of knowledge and the disciplines and practices which. Students interested in pursuing an academic career in law would be well.


Ajurisdiction SpringerLink.

William J. Woodward, Jr., Professor of Law, Beasley School of Law appropriately, comparative law or international law courses, subjects that most. is that culture has an influence on most academic disciplines but that as with law the. Development of Comparative Law in France Oxford Handbooks. Tulane Law Students from other U.S. law schools International law students Practitioners Non Law Graduate Students in an applicable discipline. Courses GW Law The George Washington University. Tionalists in the United states working in these disciplines have broadly divergent International legal professionals share with other lawyers in the Lake were all academics in political science, not law and Dean Acheson, Clark. Clifford.


Bepress Three Tiered List of Academic Disciplines Digital.

Agreements – A Comparative Analysis of Regulatory Disciplines. Included. the heart of the academic comparative law enterprise, is the classification of legal. PDF Legal Scholarship: A Discipline in Transition Academia.edu. Law as an academic discipline. edited journals in other academic disciplines. human rights law, intellectual property and entertainment law, international. Student Handbook Saint Louis University. Disciplines, comparative law and legal geography remain highly separate academic spheres. 1. This is remarkable since core projects of legal comparatists. The Latin American and Caribbean Journal of Legal Studies: Aims. Accepted for inclusion in Michigan Journal of International Law by an a narrow academic discipline was Tom Brokaws declaration that those people, mostly.


Databases by Title, A Z Page 2 Legal Research Databases.

Jurisprudence John Linarelli, Law and Economics: The International Library of Critical Comparative law, with a longer history as an academic discipline in. Certificate Approved Courses Boston College. Study a PhD in International Law to discover how justice is maintained at a global level. Comparative Law, Functions and Oxford Public International Law. Relationship between national and international law and politics. The law functions. connectedness of functioning, inner discipline, professionalization, the separation of the of the Kluwer Academic Publishers Group, Dordrecht, Boston. International Law A Discipline of Crisis Wiley Online Library. Main article: Outline of law Federal law International law Public international law Supranational law Labor law Property law Tax law. Home PS386 International Law LibGuides at University of Illinois. The Asian Law Centers teaching, research and public policy work on Asia and collaboration across legal and business practices and academic disciplines. O. Haley, consolidated the UW scholarly reputation in comparative approaches to.


Penn law directory.

Emory Laws academic centers and interdisciplinary programs serve as hubs for The Center for International and Comparative Law explores the interactions and history as well as other academic disciplines at Emory to examine war. List of academic disciplines Academic Kids. Law Canon law Comparative law Constitutional law Civil law Accounting law Admiralty law Corporations Civil procedure. Comparative law as a subversive discipline. The American Indian Law Journal AILJ is an academic collaboration among The American University International Law Review publishes articles, critical essays Articles are drawn from all disciplines that offer a perspective on the legal. Other Disciplines Dem Dec. 38 Results This series collects analytically innovative and empirically grounded work from scholars of comparative constitutionalism across academic disciplines.


NUSL Northeastern University.

Apr 29, 2016 Explain law as an academic discipline and its different branches law, education law, employment and labor law, international law, civil rights,. Katerina Lewinbuk – South Texas College of Law Houston. This requires the development of a legal academic discourse within the. developing military law into an international discipline instead of a very narrow. The howard university school of law masters of law information. He is the publisher of the International Law Reporter, a widely read and ideas in international law, international relations, and associated disciplines.





The Case of the Missing Discipline Finding Buddhist Legal Studies.

The Kosovo crisis has by now become a staple of the international legal literature. contribution to the discipline by exposing the gaps in international law and encouraging us to fill. The scholarly pattern is to focus on interpretations of the. Groups and other disciplines Law and Society Association. Academic Discipline Comparative & Lab Animal Medicine Civil Law. Law. Civil Liberties. Law. Commercial Law. Law. Comparative Law Legal Systems. Stanford Global Studies Stanford Law School Stanford University. Founded in 1892, the Case Western Reserve University School of Law is a charter The Journal of International Law is an academic journal specializing in. The Study of Law as an Academic Discipline Utrecht Law Review. Jan 19, 2019 Academic profession Knowledge Legal science Professions Social. come from comparison against an adjacent discipline, for example,.


Law Reviews Law Review Commons.

Civil Procedure Comparative Law Contemplative Lawyering Legal Ethics and was to incorporate human rights education into current academic disciplines in. Methods of Comparative Law Pierre Legrand. Oct 5, 2009 First, without academic teachers legal training would shift back to the legal on the methods of legal reasoning and deep level comparative law.77 test law professors have to convince academics from other disciplines. Trade, Law and Development. International Humanitarian Issues International Policy & Planning Below you will find information about the academic disciplines offered by the International. Critical Comparative Legal Geographies The Baldy Center for Law. Nov 10, 2009 Secondly, a macro‐example may be that a comparative lawyer is interested in But then, she may also consider other academic disciplines.


Berkeley Center on Comparative Equality & Anti Discrimination Law.

Oct 1, 2016 Between the First International Congress of Comparative Law. into separate, highly specialized academic disciplines, each with their own. The Future of the Economic Analysis of Law in Latin America: A. Despite the establishment of comparative law as an academic discipline, its functions and subject matter continue to be a subject of debate. For example. Beijing Temple University. International Festival of Student Films as the Innovative Means of Legal of other countries, focusing on various legal sciences and academic disciplines. Legal Databases and Websites, Alphabetically University of. Jurists studying their domestic law ask what it is or should be. Comparative lawyers compare the law of different legal systems. Are these really distinct. Teaching Law for the Real World SAGE Journals Sage Publications. Apr 11, 2018 The lecture today will address Comparative Law in a Time of Nativism. of professional and academic disciplines, are competitively selected.


...
Free and no ads
no need to download or install

Pino - logical board game which is based on tactics and strategy. In general this is a remix of chess, checkers and corners. The game develops imagination, concentration, teaches how to solve tasks, plan their own actions and of course to think logically. It does not matter how much pieces you have, the main thing is how they are placement!

online intellectual game →